Detecting and indicating system for explosive gases



May 18, 1948. c. B. STALLSMITH DETECTING AND INDICATING SYSTEM FOR EXPLOSIVE GASES Filed April 11, 1945 Y Rm E o m N T/ R N w; m E5 T v A 5 r w Y w\\ 5 NY \N\\ mu N w m i Q m 1 Q H m Tu QL WM w R wvw Ks mm mm 0Q m L Q x. r T Q a T & l wrwN PM. QN R.N\ P

Patented May 18, 1948 DETECTING AND INDICATING SYSTEM FOR EXPLOSIVE GASES Clare B. Stallsmith, Los Angeles, Calif., assignor, by mesne assignments, to Sam Abrams, Max Abrams, Ben Abrams, and Joe Abrams, Los Angeles, Calif., individually and as partners, doing business as Abrams Investment 00.

Application April-11, 1945, Serial No. 587,802

Claims.

This invention relates to the detection of gaseous mixtures. More particularly, it relates to the timely detection of dangerous mixtures of explosive gases. In this way, alarm signals are automatically energized whenever the gas mixture under test approaches a dangerous condition that may cause an explosion.

In many industrial applications, vapors or gases capable of forming an explosive mixture in the atmosphere may escape and create a serious hazard to life and property. Hazards of this character are also encountered in mines, or other subterranean localities, where gases may collect.

The timely detection of dangerous mixtures of gases before they reach an amount of concentration to be explosive has been the subject of much research. The most practical manner discovered so far in which to do this is to utilize the effect of catalysis on a fine platinum wire or filament of such gases. While other metals or materials besides platinum might be used for this purpose, there are many practical considerations for the choice of platinum as being the most suitable for this purpose. Use of such catalytic eflect is made as follows:

The heat generated by the catalytic reaction of the gases it is desired to detect with the platinum filament causes a change in the electric resistance of the filament.

I In order that such changes in temperature be made useful, the corresponding change in electric resistance of the filament is used to affect an electrical circuit. The conventional manner in which this change of electrical resistance is made useful is to connect this platinum filament in one of the branches of a Wheatstone bridge circuit, which circuit is well known in the electrical arts as a means of measuring differences or changes of electrical resistance.

However, there are several characteristics of the Wheatstone bridge circuit that must be observed in its use. One of these is that the arm or bridge of the circuit against which the unknown resistance is bein calibrated must be accurate and the leads and all characteristics of the unknown resistance must be accurately calibrated in relationship to the other branches of the bridge circuit. Another characteristic is that when the amount of deflection of a galvanometer or null-indicating device of the Wheatstone bridge is calibrated and used as a means of indicating the amount of change of one of the arms of the bridge from a predetermined standard, the

in electrical current applied to the bridge must be maintained uniform in order to maintain the accuracy of such indications.

Another characteristic of the bridge circuit is that the amount of current flowing through the 5 null-indicating device, when the bridge is not balanced, is not necessarily representative of the change in resistance in oneof the branches; for example, if there was a change of .l ampere of current in one of the arms of the bridge, there would not be .1 ampere of current flowing between the null points" of the bridge. The current flowing between the null points of a bridge when the bridge is unbalanced is a resultant of the potential difference between the voltage drops across which the null indicator is connected.

From this characteristic it might be seen that in order to have a large indication in the nullindicating device to indicate a small change in resistance of one of the arms of the bridge, it is necessary either tonave a very sensitive null indicating device or to pass large amounts of current through the arms of the bridge. Since for practical reasons the amount of current that can be passed through the arms of the bridge is limited because of the current carrying capacity of the resistors and the current supplying capacity of the power source involved it is necessary to resort either to extremely sensitive motor movements or elaborate amplifying systems to give adequate indication of bridge unbalance to use in a practical manner.

Since current-flow indicating devices' of a direct reading type made for alternating" currents are relatively insensitive compared to direct reading instruments designed for use on direct currents, it has, up to the present time, been found necessary to use direct current on such bridge circuits.

.This difficulty is mentioned in patents previ ously issued on gas detecting devices.

As has been mentioned previously, one of the requirements for accuracy in use of a Wheatstone bridge is the necessity for all arms of the bridge to be accurately balanced in relationship to each, other for a condition of null. It is well known that as the amount of current flowing in a circuit increases the difliculty of accurately balancing resistors in that circuit increases. If it became necessary to change the detector element" or filament in the conventional bridge circuit, it would be necessary to calibrate that resistance to the bridge circuit or vary one of ;th e other branches'of the bridge circuit to compensate for variatigns in the filament that is use'd'for across either pair of adjacent arms of the bridge replacement. The order of currents being used in these circuit makes this an operation that is quite delicate, would require the use of highly skilled personnel and a use of highly precise equipment.

It is an object of this invention to eliminate such obstacles in the replacement of detector elements and make it possible for such elements to be replaced in the filament with very little attendant trouble.

Another difliculty that must be met in the use of a Wheatstone bridge circuit iscorrection for ambient temperature changes of the atmosphere in which the bridge is being used. This has been done to more or less degree by inserting in the arm opposite to the resistance being measured a resistance with a fairly high temperature coeflicient. But this only takes care of the problem of ambient temperature variation to a certain degree because using change in resistance of such compensating resistor and the resistor being measured, the current flowing through the bridge will vary and means must be provided to vary the applied current directly proportional to such current change.

In dealing with a very small order of currents this could be done in a practical manner in several diiferent ways but the range of currents required in devices of this nature preclude the use of such means for maintaining constant current to the bridge; hence all devices using such Wheatstone bridge circuits must either be used in an atmosphere of a predetermined temperature, or correction factors be applied for use of such devices in ambient temperatures other than for which the device was calibrated.

Another weakness or difilculty encountered in the use of the Wheatstone bridge is the amount of power available developed across the null points of the bridge for the purpose of operating alarms or signal devices. Since such alarm control circuits must of necessity operate on very small amounts of power, it has been customary in most present-day devices to use a very small sensitive direct indicating type meter as a null indicator which has included in it a means for controlling an electrical circuit. Since any of the changes mentioned in the preceding paragraphs will cause an error in the accuracy of indication of such meters, it follows that the control of any circuits by such meters will be changed plied to the bridge circuit would change in value and hence change the accuracy of indication of resistance change of any of the arms of the bridge. I,

It is one of the objects of this invention to make it possible in a simple and reliable manner with changes in applied current or ambient temperature. The peculiar construction of such current-control current indicating devices is such that there is a minimum accuracy of control that can be depended upon. Such current control action most often depends upon a small magnet being held on an arm which is adjustable to a predetermined position and which attracts a small piece of steel affixed to the instrument pointer; since all magnets change their coercive force with, age, the leeway of adjustment permissible'varies with time, thus introducing additional error.

Another weak point of such direct indicating and current control devices is the use of a permanent magnet in th movement of such devices which is bound to change in time. A third point in the use of the aforementioned system is that the use of these devices on commercial alternating current requires the use of some means of rectifying to furnish direct current for the operation of the bridge. Since all present means of such rectification systems are subject to variation or change, this means that the cur ent to compensate for variations in ambient temperature.

It is another object of this invention to make use of alternating current to eliminate the need for rectifiers and voltage regulators.

It is another object of this invention to use the small change in resistance occurring in the platinum Wire in a practicable manner without the need of extremely delicate or sensitive instruments.

It is another object of this invention to provide a means of testing th operativeness of this system.

The catalytic action of a gaseous constituent is also dependent upon the specified gas or gases that must be detected. Accordingly, the mere choice of a different resistance is insufllcient to insure accurate indication of dangerous explosive mixtures. On the contrary, some adjustment must be made for the type of gas involved. It is therefore another object of this invention to make it possible readily to adjust the apparatus for such differences in the types of said gases and especially by providing adjustments of the circuits associated with electronic emission devices. The temperature change caused by catalytic action of a gaseous constituent also varies with the temperature of the platinum filament. By that is meant that the amount of temperature change caused by such catalytic action at one temperature is different for the catalytic eifect of the same percentage of gaseous constituent at another temperature of the filament.

It is another object of this invention to provide a means for automatically compensating for this diiference in amount of change of temperature on the detector filament caused by catalytic action of gaseous constituents.

It is still another object of this invention to provide a compact system of this character, and particularly by the employment of the electronic emission device to utilize the relatively small current variations resulting from temperature variations caused byvariations in the constituents of the atmosphere being tested.

This invention possesses many other advantages and has other objects which may be made more clearly-apparent from a consideration of one embodiment of the invention. For this purpose there is shown a form in the drawings accompanying and forming a part of the present specification. The form will now be described in detail, illustrating the general principles of the invention, but it is to be understood that this detailed description is not to be taken in a limited sense. The scope of this invention is best defined by the appended claims.

Referring to the drawings the single figure is a diagrammatic representation of a system incorporating the invention.

The detector system is intended to be used in a locality where explosive mixtures may occur, such as in the hold of a vessel, subterranean passages, in factories where explosive gases are utilized, or out in the open.

An apparatus l, for sampling the atmosphere, is shown adjacent the upper left-hand corner of the figure. This apparatus is placed so that a current of air can pass through it. Accordingly,

manor:

vby the creation of heat in the sampling apparatus. The air is intended to enter through a screen 2 and to pass out of the sampling apparatus through a screen 3.

Within the apparatus I are located a pair of flame arresters, or barriers 4 and 5, between which are located a pair of filamentary elements 6, and I,- such as annealed platinum adapted tobe heated to an initial temperature by application of an alternating current. The appae ratus also includes a fan 8 for inducing the current of air through the apparatus. The fan is shown as driven by an electric motor 9. This fan and motor are used where there would not. be sufiicient movement of room atmosphere or sufficient diflusion of constituent gases to affect the detector filaments in a reasonable length of time. It may be desired to insert the filaments in a vent where there are strong currents of air or in places where there would be a high rate of diffusion of gases.

The elements 6 and I are filamentary in character and are wound to a spiral to condense their size. As is well known, element 6, which is exposed to the constituent atmosphere, is capable of catalytic reaction as previously described.

In the present instance, this known property is utilized for setting an alarm system into operation when the concentration of the explosive gaseous constituent in the atmosphere reaches a value dangerously close to the explosive range of concentration. The range of concentration in which flame propagation is so rapid as to be classed as an explosion is readily determinable; and, accordingly, the corresponding temperature range attained by element 6 results in a definite corresponding variation in resistance of the element.

While the element 6 is exposed to the atmorphere, the element I is enclosed in a vessel III in which there is an inert gas, such as nitrogen. The elements 6 and I'. with supplemental apparatus to be hereinafter described, are accurately matched with each other so that element I has identical resistance with element 6 when their temperatures are equal; and furthermore, due

to the use of an inert gas filling in good thermal contact with the external atmosphere, the element 1 is subjected to the temperature of the circumambient atmosphere.

Accordingly, the difference in temperatures of elements 6 and I can only be caused by catalytic action of element 6, causing a difference of its resistance which, in turn, may be used to measure the concentration of explosive gases. Therefore, by aid of the variation in differences in resistance between these two elements, we can determine whether the atmosphere to which element 6 is exposed is dangerously close to an explosive mixture. 7

Electric power for the operatieon of the entire system is supplied by the mains II and I2 connected to a commercial source. A plug I3 is intended to be received in a receptacle I4 for connecting the system to the mains.

The motor 9 is energized from the mains by operation of a switch I5. Thus, the circuit for the motor 9 may be traced as follows: main II, left-hand portion of receptacle I4, left-hand prong of plug I3, fuse I6, switch I5, connections I! and I8, motor 9, another fuse I9, conductor 6 20, right-hand prong or plug I3, right-hand portion of receptacle I4, to main I2.

The alternating current passing through elements 6 and I is supplied through an appropriate step-down transformer 2I, that provides an electromotive force of about six volts across the filaments. The primary winding 22 of this transformer is fed from the mains II and I2 through the following circuit: main II, receptacle I4. plug I3, fuse I6, switch blade is, conductor 23, primary winding 22, conductor 24, plug I3, receptacle I4 to main I2. The secondary winding 25 of transformer 2I is connected to supply current to the elements 6 and I in parallel. Thus. the circuit for the exposed element 6 may be traced as follows: from the right-hand terminal of winding 25, a resistance 26, conductor 21, element 6, conductor 28, primary winding 29 of a transformer 30, to the left-hand terminal of secondary winding' 25. Resistance 26 has a value determining the desired current through the elements 6 and I.

The circuit for element 1 is traced from secondary 25, through resistance 26, conductor 21, element I, conductor 33, primary winding 34 ofa transformer 35, back to the transformer winding 25.

When an explosive gas mixture is present, the temperature of element 6 increases, while the temperature of element I is unaffected by the gaseous constituent. Accordingly, the resistance of element 6 is increased, and the current flow through it is reduced. The primarywinding 29 thus carries less current than before. 'This inequality of current flow is then effective to operate an electronic'emission device, such as a thyratron 88, which causes an alarm system to operate. The mode of operation of this device 88 will be described hereinafter.

The manner in which the controlling potential differences are obtained by aid of transformers 30 and will now be described. Secondary winding 36 of transformer 30 supplies current to resistors I30 and I3I in series. the secondary current, however. is shunted so as to be rectified by the aid of a double diode rectifier tube 38.

. 40. The cathode 40 is heated by the heater 4|,

supplied with electric energy in a manner to be hereinafter described. The heater 4I supplies heat as well for the cathode 42 for the left-hand portion of the tube 38. This left-hand portion of the tube 38 is provided with a plate or anode 43.

The rectifying circuit for a portion of the current flowing through the winding 36 may ,be

Paralleling the rectifier electrodes 39 and 40' is a circuit including that portion of resistor I30 which is below tap 44, resistor I3I, and connec- A portion of tion I35 to the upper terminal of winding 36. By adjusting tap 44, the quantity of rectified current is adjusted. Furthermore, the resistor I30 can be made much smaller than resistor I3I in order to provide a fine adjustment. For example, while resistor I3I may be as high as 20,000 to 25,000 ohms, resistor I30 is made from about 750 to 1,000 ohms. By adjustment of tap 44, therefore, proper calibration of the circuits associated with filament 6 may be obtained.

The rectified current flowing through resistance 31 is a measure of the temperature of the element 6. Accordingly, the potential difference across the resistance 31 is also a measure or that temperature. If desired, a continuously operating graphic recorder 48 of any desired type may be connected across the resistance 31, which by appropriate calibration indicates and records the concentration of the explosive gas in the air stream.

winding 49 of the transformer 35 is rectified by aid of the left-hand electrodes 42--43 oi the double diode 38. This rectifying circuit may be traced as follows: from the lower terminal 01' the winding 49, through a portion of resistor I32, tap I33, conductor 50, electrodes 43 and 42, resistance ground 52 and ground 53 to the upper terminal of the winding 49. As before, a by-pass condenser 54 may be connected across the terminals of resistance 5I.

The connections to the transformer winding 49 are such that the upper terminal 55 of resistance 5I is positive with respect to ground.

Paral-leling the rectifier electrodes 42 and 43 is a circuit including that portion of resistor I32 which is below tap I36, resistor I33, push button I40, and connection I4I to the upper terminal of winding 49. By adjustment of tap I36, the quantity of rectified current is adjusted. Again, the adjustment may be made fine bychoosing resistor I32 of low value with respect to resistor I33: for example, resistor I32 can be from 750 to 1,000 ohms, and resistor I33 can be from 20,000 to 25,000 ohms.

By adjustment of taps 44 and I36, the drops across resistors 31 and 5I are equal when the stream of air through the apparatus I has no explosive gaseous constituent therein.

When push button I40 is operated, the current that is rectified through electrodes 42, 43 is increased, since the circuit paralleling these elctrodes is opened. There is accordingly a rise in voltage across resistance 5|. This has the same effect as a decrease in voltage across resistor 31, which may be caused by a dangerous explosive condition. This afiords a means of quickly checking the operation of the unit to see whether it is in condition to respond to such conditions.

The currents flowing through resistances 31 and 5I may be directly opposed to. create a controlling potential for the thyratron 88. These resistances may also be of the order of 25,000 ohms. If, due to these currents, the potential differences across these resistances are equal, the thyratron is unafiected. If, however, the potential difference across resistance 31 is reduced due to the reduction in current flow through transformer winding 36, then there is a potential effective to operate the thyratron 88. How these potential differences are utilized will be explained hereinafter.

As heretofore mentioned, the temperature attained by the exposed element 6, when subjected to a mixture including an explosive gas constitu- A portion of the current through the secondary ent, depends upon the temperature that would be attained by the exposed element when heated by the alternating current, and in an innocuous atmosphere. The lower this initial temperature is, the greater the catalytic action for the same concentration. There is apt to be some variation in the electromotive force available across mains II and I2, and which, in turn, causes a variation in the heating currents. Ordinarily, the variation is so small that it may be ignored, and by proper choice of the design of transformers 30 and 35, the errors caused by line voltage variation may be greatly reduced. However, in this instance, further automatic compensation is provided for.

Thus, assuming that there is a reduction in the electromotive force considerably below normal, a reduction in the initial temperature of element 6 results, and therefore, an increased catalytic action. Accordingly, at any specific concentration of the gaseous constituent, the increase over the initial temperature is greater, and there is a greater difference between the drops across resistances 31 and 5I. To maintain this differential at the same value as when the electromotive force across mains II and I2 is at the normal value, use is made of a compensating circuit, including the electronic emission amplifier device 51. v

This device is shown as a triode having an indirectly heated cathode 58, a control electrode or grid 59, and an anode or plate 60. The cathode 58 is shown as heated by a heater 6| which is supplied with a heating current in a manner to and I2 by way of plug I3, fuse I6, and switch blade [5. The power supply also includes a double diode rectifier 'II, having the anodes 60, I0, and a cathode 12 which is indirectly heated by the heater I3, energized by the transformer and filter'system 62. The output of the rectifier system includes the conductor I'I, corresponding to a potential above ground, and the ground connection 66.

We may now consider how amplifier 51 is used to reduce the effect of variations in the electromotive force across mains II and I2. For this purpose, values by way of an example may be assigned to the factors entering into this problem.

Let us assume that there is present a 5 percent mixture of explosive gases in the atmosphere being investigated; that the catalytic effect of these ases on element 6 is increased by 20 percent at the lower operating temperature caused by a line voltage reduction or ambient temperature reduction.

Accordingly, in order to compensate for this increased catalytic action, it is necessary to cause the control electrode 89 of thyratron 88 to maintain this thyratron inactive for this 20 percent increase over normal catalytic action. Since this control electrode is maintained negative with respect to cathode until the triggering action occurs, this compensation requires that an additional negative bias be Placed on grid 89; this negative voltage is measured so as to retard the decrease of negative potential by 20 percent of such grid voltage changes as normal operation. Thus for example, for normal line voltage,

9 a potential change on grid 88 oi +.1 volt is required to indicated the presence or the 8 percent mixture of gas; then for a reduced'line voltage or reduced ambient temperature, the same mixture of gas applied to element 8 causes a potential change on grid 88 of +.1 volt 20 percent of .1 volt, or +.12 volt. Therefore, in some way, a compensating .02 volt must be created.

For this purpose, the electronic emission tube 51 is utilized. Proper plate supply to plate or anode 88 of this tube is obtained by aid of the voltage divider made up of resistors 18 and 82, and ground 84 connected to' the positive potential conductor 11 or the power supply system.

Condenser 88 provides additional filtering or the.

plate supply.

Cathode 58 is grounded at ground 18 through resistor 88. which is bridged by another filtering condenser 8|. By proper selection or this resistor 88, voltage changes produced across it due to voltage changes on grid 58 of tube 51, may be such as required for the compensation.

When the system is operating on normal line voltage (say 115 volts) and in a gas-free atmosphere, the voltage across resistor 88 is equal to, but opposite in polarity to the voltage across resistor 81. Hence the signal voltage on grid 88 of tube 88 is zero. This signal voltage is impressed by aid of connection 81. In the presence of gas, when element 8 will be affected, the voltage across resistor 81 is less than the voltage across resistor 88, and a positive potential corresponding to the difference is impressed on grid 88.

But the voltage across resistor 88 is also a function of the voltage across resistor This is so because the drop across resistor 5| is efiective on the grid 58 of tube 51, by way of connection 88, and thereby this drop controls the plate current through resistor 88.

Now, should the line voltage or ambient temperature -decrease, thus lowering the temperature of elements 8 and 1, the drops across resistors SI and 81 will each be reduced in the same proportion as the line voltage or ambient temperature. However, due to the amplification factor oftube 51, there will be a greater change in voltage across resistor 88 than across resistor 81 or 5|. Therefore, instead of a zero signal potential on grid 88 of tube 88, there will appear a negative voltage. This means that a greater change in voltage (due to presence of an explosive gas) will be necessary across resistor 81 to cause tube 88 to fire. This greater change occurs as a result of the increased catalytic action at the lowered filament temperatures.

Similar but opposite effects :occur when the line voltage or ambient temperature increases. In that case, the change in voltage across resistor .88 is in a positive direction and is again greater than the change in voltage across resistor 81 or The connections for the thyratron 88 may now be more particularly specified. It is now well known that, when a definite potential difl'erence exists between grid 88 and the cathode 88, a heavy space current fiows between the anode 88 and the cathode; and this continues to flow even 7 after the control grid potential would no longer be capable of initiating the current fiow.

The cathode 88 is heated by a heater I81, sup- ;plied with current in a manner to be hereinafter idescribed. The plate or anode 88 is kept at a .Qpositive potential by being connected to lead 11 through a ciuz'uit interrupting pushbutton I88, a relay coil 97, and a resistance 88. A by-pass condenser 88 is placed in parallel to the relay 'coil 81. Resistance 88 serves to place the potential of the plate 88 with respectto the cathode 88 at the desired value. The cathode 88 is grounded through resistances 8| and I88. These resistances may be determined. Adjustment of tap I48 is required to determine the sensitivity of the thyratron 88. a

' We may now return to the controlling function of grid 88, and the derivation oi. a controlling potential. Normally, since there is a drop across both resistances 81 and 88, a current can flow from the positive side of resistance 88, through ground connections 18, 48, resistance 81, and connection 81, back to resistance '88. Grid 88 is connected, via connection 81, to the negative side 88 of resistance 81, and to the positive side 01' resistance 88. Cathode 88 is connected, via resistance 8| and ground connections 82, 48 and 18, to the positive side of resistance 81 and the negative side of resistance 88.

It may readily be demonstrated that, when the .drops across these resistances 81 and 88 are equal,

the potential of grid 88 with respect to cathode 88 I depends upon the potential of tap I48 above ground. The grid potential is negatively biased by that drop. This is sufilcient to keep the thyratron inactive. Now, if the drop across resistance 81 is reduced, the potential of grid '88 moves toward positive; and, if the reduction is suflicient (due to catalytic action of element 8) the grid 88 triggers the thyratron, and a heavy current fiow results. This is made to occur at a definite concentration of the explosive gases. The fiow of current can be stopped by operation of push button I88. Ordinarily, a decrease of the drop across resistance 81 of about one volt is sufllcient to set the thyratron 88 into operation.-

The trigger action may be adjusted to take place optionally at any per cent value of the concentration corresponding to the lower explosive.

level. This is mainly accomplished by adjustment of tap 48 on resistance I88. However, another adjustment is provided by aid of the suppressor grid electrode 84. The potential of this grid also affects the potential that grid 88 must reach to set the device into operation. To adjust this potential of grid 84, a tap on resistance 8| is connected, as by lead I82, to the grid 84. Adjustment of tap 85 on the relatively high resistance 8| is most useful for adjusting the response of the thyratron 88 to a specific type of gas; and tap I48 on the relatively low resistance I88 is most useful to adjust for the percentage concentration.

Relay 81, when energized, operates an alarm system IN by aid 01' the relay contacts I82. This alarm system |8| may be at a remote point from the installation. A local alarm system which may include a lamp I84 and a buzzer I85 may be op- 'erated upon energization of the relay coil 81 nected'in parallel across leads 88, 84. The ar-' rangement is furthermore such that, should any one of the heater circuits be interrupted or broken for any reason, a signalling system will be set into operation. An interruption in the supply of electrical energy to the system will also affect an alarm system.

For this purpose, each of the heater circuits includes a relay coil in series with the heater. Thus, the heater circuit for heater 4| includes the relay coil 14; the heater circuit for heater 6| includes a relay coil I08; the heater circuit for heater 13 includes the relay coil I09; and, finally, the heater circuit for heater I01 includes a relay coil H0. Each of these coils has a set of back contacts III, H2 H3, or H4, which is open when the corresponding relay is energized, and closed in the event the heater circuit is opened, deenergizing the relay coil. Dropping of the armatures of any one or more of the relays will, therefore, close the circuit of a relay H5. This circuit includes the conductors H6 and H1 across which all of the sets of relay contacts II I, H2, H3, and H4 are connected. The relay circuit may then be traced from any of the closed contacts through connection I6, coil H5, an auxiliary source of power, such as the battery H8, connection H9, switch blade I20, and back to connection II'I. Blade I20 forms, with blade 15, a double pole single throw switch. Accordingly, whenever the system is set into operation by closure of switch I5, the relay circuit just traced will be set to operate in the event of failure of any one of the heater circuits.

When the relay H is energized, set-s of contacts l2l and I22 are closed. One set I2I controls an alarm system I23 at a remote station. The other set of contacts I22 controls the energization of a signalling lamp or other signal I24, through battery H8 and connections I25 and I26.

The mode of operation of the system may now be briefly stated. While the stream of air flowing through apparatus l' is free of an explosive constituent, the elements 6 and I are heated to the same degree by the alternating current source represented by the transformer 2 I. Accordingly, the drops across the resistances 31 and 80 are balanced. The control electrode 89 of the device 88 has a potential preventing the flow of current to the plate 93. Accordingly, relay coil 91 is deenergized.

In the event the atmosphere to which the element 6 is subjected carries a gaseous constituent that approaches closely to an explosive stage, the temperature of element 6 is increased above that of element 1. The drop across resistance 31 is then reduced, while that across resistance'80 stays the same. This reduces the negative potential of grid 89 sufiiciently to permit the thyratron to operate. The alarm system IN, and the visible and audible signals I04 and I05, are all energized. They remain energized until push button I00 is operated.

By operation of push button I40, the system may be tested, since then a heavier current is permitted to be rectified by device 38, and this heavier current raises the potential of point 55.

This in turn increases the drop across resistance 80. and therefore increases the potential on grid 89 of the thyratron 88 to a triggering value.

When the electromotive force of the source of energy varies, the result is a variation in the catalytic action of the element 6. This is automatically compensated for by the use of the triode 51 which operates to maintain the potential of the control electrode 89 at the same value withina wide range of variation of thepower lines.

The inventor claims:

1. In a system adapted to respond to the presence of an explosive gaseous constituentin the atmosphere, and including a pair of similar filamentary elements, one exposed to the air at the locality under test, and heated by catalytic action by the presence of an explosive gaseous constituent, and the other element being enclosed in an inert gaseous atmosphere free of explosives, and subjected to substantially identical temperature conditions as'the exposed element: the combination therewith of means for passing an alternating current through said elements in parallel circuits, said current sewing to raise the temperatures of the elements to proper operating temperature to increase the resistance of the elements; a pair of transformer means respectively associated with the parallel circuits for deriving currents corresponding to the resistances of the elements; a rectifier and a resistance in series with each of said transformer means; means for placing in opposition, the

. potential differences across said resistances; and

an electronic emission device responding to the opposed potential diiferences and initiated into operation upon sufficient excess of one potential difference over the other.

2. In a system adapted to respond to the presence of an explosive gaseous constituent in the atmosphere, and including a pair of similar filamentary elements, one exposed to the atmosphere at the locality under test, and heated by catalytic action by the presence of an explosive gaseous constituent, and the other element being enclosed in an atmosphere free of explosive gases, and subjected to the same temperature conditions as the exposed element: the combination therewith of means for passing an alternating current through said elements in parallel circuits, said current serving to raise the temperatures of the elements and thereby to increase the resistance of the elements; a pair of transformer means respectively associated with the parallel circuits for deriving currents corresponding to the resistances of the elements; a rectifier and a resistance in series with each of said transformer means; means for placing in opposition, the potential differences across said resistances; an electronic emission device responding to the opposed potential differences and initiated into operation upon sufficient excess of one potential difierence over the other; and an alarm system controlled by said electronic emission device.

3. In a system adapted to respond to the presence of an explosive gaseous constituent in the atmosphere, and including a pair of similar filamentary elements. one exposed to the atmosphere at the locality under test, and heated by the catalytic action of the explosive gaseous constituent, and the other element being enclosed in an inert gaseous atmosphere free of explosives, and subjected to substantially identical temperature conditions as the exposed element: the combination therewith of means for passing an alternating current through said elements in parallel circuits, said current serving to raise the temperatures of the elements and thereby to increase the resistance of the elements; a pair of transformer means respectively associated with the parallel circuits for deriving currents corresponding to the resistances of the elements; a rectifier anda resistance in series with each of said transformer means; a first electronic emission device controlled in accordance with variations in the potential difference across one of the resistance; an output circuit for said electronic emission device, including an impedance, the drop across 13 said impedance being opposed to the drop across the other resistance. and so arranged that variations in electromotive force of the source of supply result in no substantial variation in the effective value of the potential diiference resulting from the opposed drops; and a second electronic emission device responding to said eifective value.

4. In a system adapted to respond to the presence of an explosive gaseous constituent in the atmosphere, and including a pair of similar filamentary elements, one exposed to the atmosphere at the locality under test, and heated partly by catalytic action of an explosive gaseous constituent, and the other element being enclosed in an inert gaseous atmosphere free of explosives. and subjected to substantially identical temperature conditions as the exposed element: .the combination therewith of means for passing an alternating current through said elements in parallel circuits, said current serving to raise the temperatures of the elements and thereby to increase the resistance of the elements; a pair of transformer means respectively associated with the parallelcircults for deriving currents corresponding to the resistances of the elements; a rectifier and a resistance in series with each of said transformer means; a first electronic emission device controlled in accordance with variations in the p tential diiference across one of the resistance; an

output circuit for said electronic emission device, including an impedance, the dro across said impedance being opposed to the drop across the other resistance, and so arranged that variations in electromotive force of the source of supply result in no substantial variation in the effective value of the potential diiference resulting from the opposed drops; a second electronic emission device responding to said eifective value; and an alarm system controlled by said second electronic emission device.

5. In a device of the character described, an element the resistance of which is a function of its temperature; a circuit for passing an alternat ing heating current through said member; a transformer having a primary winding included in said circuit. as well as a secondary winding; 2. rectifier fed from the secondary winding; a first resistor fed with current from the rectifier to produce .a potential drop across the resistance; a second resistor; means for causing a direct current potential drop across said second resistor; and control means responsive to the diiference in the potential drops; and operative'upona predetermined diiferential between said potential drops.

6. In a device of the character described, an element tthe resistance of which is a function of its temperature; a circuit for passing an alternating heating current through said member; a transformer having a primary winding included in said circuit, as well as a secondary winding; a rectifier fed from the secondary winding; a first resistor fed with current from the rectifier to produce a potential drop across the resistance; a second resistor; means for causing a direct current potential drop across said second resistor; control means responsive to the diiference in the potential drops; and operative upon a predetermined diiferential between said potential drops; and means for testing said system by increasing the potential drop across said second resistor.

7. In a device of the character described: a pair of elements the resistances of which are functions of their temperatures; a circuit having parallel branches respectively for passing an alternating v 14 heating current through said elements; a pair of transformers having primary windings respectively in said branches, and having secondary windings; rectifier means supplied by said secondary windings; a pair of resistors respectively fed from said secondary windings; means providing an adjustable load for each of said secondary windings; and control means operating in response to the diiferential in the potential diflerences produced respectively by said loads across said resistors.

8. In a device of the character described: a

pair of elements the resistances of which are.

functions of their temperatures; a circuit having parallel branches respectively for passing an alt'ernating heating current through said elements; a pair of transformers having primary windings respectively in said branches, and having secondary windings; a pair of rectifier means respectively supplied by said secondary windings; a pair of resistors respectively fed from said secondary windings; at least a part of each of said resistors being in series respectively with a rectiiier means; means providing an adjustable load for each of said secondary windings; control means operating in response to the differential in the potential differences across said resistors; and means for open-circuiting the adjustable load for one of said secondary windings.

9. In asystem of the character described: a pair of resistors; means utilizing an impressed electromotive force for creating a potential drop across each resistor; means whereby the difi'erential in said potential drops is a function of the electromotive force; a third resistor; and means operating in response to a change in electromotive force for maintaining the diiferential between the drop across said third resistor and one of the other resistors, independently of the variation in electromotive force.

10. In a system of the character described: a pairof resistors; means utilizing an electromotive force for creating a potential drop across'each resistor; means whereby the diiferentlal in said potential drops is a function of the electromotive force; a third resistor; and means operating in response to a change in electromotive force for maintaining the difierentlal between the drop across said third resistor and one of the other resistors, independently of the variation in electromotive force, comprising an electronic emission device having a control electrode and a cathode, an output circuit for the device and including said third resistor, and means for impressing the potential drop across one of the said pair of resistors, between the. control electrode and the cathode.

- CLARE B. STAILSMI'I'H.

REFERENCES CITED The following references are of record in the file of this patent:

UNITED STATES PATENTS Date Great Britain Feb. 26, 1920 

